The Scarlet Claw
Why this pick
Another Rathbone-Holmes case, but its fogbound village setting, ominous killings, and patiently accumulated clues closely match the compact Gothic menace of The Woman in Green.
A FILM WORTH A CLOSER LOOKTHE FEATURE PRESENTATION
IF THIS ONE STAYED WITH YOU
Keep the feeling.
SIMILAR PICKS / A PERSONAL CONNECTION
Why this pick
Another Rathbone-Holmes case, but its fogbound village setting, ominous killings, and patiently accumulated clues closely match the compact Gothic menace of The Woman in Green.
Why this pick
Rathbone and Bruce investigate a string of brutal, uncanny crimes in a polished Universal mystery that shares the 1940s Holmes cycle’s shadowy atmosphere and Moriarty-adjacent sense of danger.
Why this pick
Its anonymous threats, secluded estate, and escalating murders offer the same briskly paced blend of drawing-room suspense, eerie criminal ritual, and Holmes-and-Watson teamwork.
Why this pick
A stylish adversary lures men into an elaborate criminal scheme, giving this Rathbone entry the same sophisticated villainy, psychological manipulation, and darkly elegant mystery.
Why this pick
This noir mystery turns on a protagonist being framed for murder, with a similarly taut atmosphere of planted evidence, mounting paranoia, and dangerous urban intrigue.
Finding the atmosphere, tension and little details that made this one stay with you.
Our curator needs a little longer. Please come back shortly.
No confident matches yet. Try our personal film finder.
01 / THE STORY
When several women are murdered and their forefingers severed, Holmes and Watson are called into action, but Holmes is baffled by the crimes at the start. Widower Sir George Fenwick (Paul Cavanagh), after a romantic night at the apartment of Lydia Marlowe (Hillary Brooke), is hypnotized into believing that he is responsible for the crimes. He is certain that he is guilty after he awakes from a stupor and finds a woman's forefinger in his pocket. His daughter comes to Holmes and Watson without realizing that Moriarty's henchman is following her. She tells Holmes and Watson that she found her father burying a forefinger under a pile of soil. She has dug up the forefinger and shows it to them.
02 / FACES IN THE FRAME

Sherlock Holmes
Dr. John Watson
Sir George Fenwick
Onslow
Lydia Marlowe
Professor James Moriarty
Mrs. Hudson