Urban Legend
Why this pick
A campus-set whodunit slasher with a similarly playful interest in teenage anxieties, gossip, and the rules people use to explain a killer’s pattern.
A FILM WORTH A CLOSER LOOKTHE FEATURE PRESENTATION
IF THIS ONE STAYED WITH YOU
Keep the feeling.
SIMILAR PICKS / A PERSONAL CONNECTION
Why this pick
A campus-set whodunit slasher with a similarly playful interest in teenage anxieties, gossip, and the rules people use to explain a killer’s pattern.
Why this pick
Its bright high-school setting and sharp, knowingly cruel humor update the teen slasher into a satirical game about image-making, friendship, and murder.
Why this pick
Like Cherry Falls, it turns a familiar American high school into a tense, suspicious pressure cooker, balancing teen banter, paranoia, and brisk genre thrills.
Why this pick
A clever teen slasher mystery whose self-awareness never overwhelms its suspense, featuring a strong heroine and a shifting web of suspects.
Why this pick
It shares Cherry Falls’ cheeky sexual politics and high-school slasher energy, while using a body-swap premise to make its heroine’s survival story unusually lively.
Finding the atmosphere, tension and little details that made this one stay with you.
Our curator needs a little longer. Please come back shortly.
No confident matches yet. Try our personal film finder.
01 / THE STORY
In the woods outside of Cherry Falls, Virginia, a teenage couple, Rod Harper (Jesse Bradford) and Stacy Twelfmann (Bre Blair) are getting romantic in a car when a black-haired female appears and murders them both. Meanwhile, in town, teenager Jody Marken (Brittany Murphy), the daughter of the local sheriff, is with her boyfriend, Kenny (Gabriel Mann), who thinks it is time to go "see other people." Jody goes back home to find her father, Brent (Michael Biehn), upset that she is out past her curfew. Brent and his deputies begin to investigate the murders the next day. They see that the killer carved the word "virgin" into both victims. At school, Brent sees English teacher Mr. Leonard Marliston (Jay Mohr), who urges him to divulge more details of the murder to students and the town so as to eliminate the possibility of secrets.
Showing saved details. Some information may be out of date.
02 / FACES IN THE FRAME

Rod Harper
Sharon

Stacy Twelfmann
Tom Sisler, Principal
Heather
Annette Duwald
Mr. Duwald

Wally